What looks good on a college application?

How to stand out in college applications

When your children send in an application to a college, something they’ve taken extensive time to develop, review, refine, and refine again, it can be daunting trying to figure out where that application is going to sit in the pile – and how it compares to other applicants.

Applying for college is an intimidating process, but to get rid of some of the fear, we sat down with Patrick Stenger, who leads our High School college counseling team, to answer the question, "What looks good on a college application?”

"In the college application process, we need to put assumptions aside on what we believe to be true about what is worth communicating to a university via the means that we have in the application process," says Mr. Stenger.

Below, we outline how students can differentiate themselves on a college application:

  • Co-curricular activities: have you engaged in your community in a quality way?
  • College essays: how have you developed and what do you bring to a community?
  • Vocabulary: use a vocabulary that is more engaging, descriptive, and active.
  • Recommendations: this is the chance to be shown in an objective light.
  • Grades and test scores: standardized test scores are important on your college application but not as important as your actual grades.
  • Honesty: show enthusiasm throughout the application.
  • Show interest: demonstrate your interest in the college!

Share this information with your community through our new infographic!

1. Co-Curricular Activities

"Many people think it’s the quantity of the engagement and not the quality. In actuality, universities worldwide aren’t looking for the staggering list of co-curricular activities, they’re looking for meaningfulness, they’re looking for significant contributions, they’re looking for leadership roles," says Mr. Stenger.

It’s important to expand the definition of leadership beyond the traditional understanding. Yes, your child could be the student class president, but they could also come up with a sustainability option for their school, pitch the idea to a campus service club and work to implement it in a meaningful way. Both are notable examples of leadership.

It’s not what they do, it’s how they contribute to those activities.

Keep in mind: if the college does not ask for supplemental information, do not send anything to them.

2. College Essays

"These writing opportunities are a student’s most obvious chance to distinguish themselves from the rest,” says Mr. Stenger. "They have to tell their story in a way that makes it easy for the reader to understand where they’re coming from, how they’ve developed, and what they bring to a community."

According to Judith Hodara, the Associate Director of Admissions for the University of Pennsylvania and the Director of Admissions for the Wharton School of Business in an article with NextStepU, the key to a commanding essay is to explore a specific moment in life.

Encourage your children to describe this important memory in vivid detail, creating a picture for the reader.

"... [For example], getting out the door when the volunteer fire department alarm goes off, or the shock of cold water when they hit the pool for swim practice. All very small instances, but they give the reader a real idea of who the student is," says Hodara.

3. Vocabulary

While your children write their application, most of it will be restrictive with the amount of space they have, so it’s important to use creativity in their word selection.

"Use a vocabulary that is more engaging, descriptive, and active," says Mr. Stenger.

Being imaginative in their writing doesn’t mean finding synonyms for every other word. It's about knowing what feeling and message they want to convey to the audience, and using what they know to communicate the story to strangers.

4. Recommendations

According to Dr. Grace Cheng Dodge, former Director of Admission, Wellesley College, MA, U.S. as well as the former Associate Director of Admissions, Harvard College, MA, U.S., if a school asks for recommendations, they put quite a bit of focus on those letters.

This is a student’s chance to show themselves in an objective light, from a perspective other than their own.

To get the best college recommendation letters, according to the College Board, a not-for-profit organization that works to expand access to higher education, applicants should do the following:

  • Speak to their references about their class participation.
  • Remind their references of specific work or projects they’re proud of (give them detailed examples).
  • Describe the lessons they learned in class.
  • If the recommendation is coming from their counselor or a school official, the student should speak with them about their hobbies, accomplishments, and plans for the future (both educationally and career-wise).

5. Grades and Test Scores

It's true that grades and test scores are of the utmost importance, but it’s within the other aspects of a college application where the applicant’s personality shines through.

With that said, colleges do look at grades, with a particular focus on course challenge. When it comes to course selection, look at academic rigor, but make sure your children keep in mind their actual abilities.

Standardized test scores are important on their college application but not as important as their actual grades.

Click here for access to free SAT practice questions and tests.

6. Honesty and Authenticity

When applicants describe their co-curricular activities, their role(s) within the community, their interests, hobbies, their experiential learning opportunities, or their academic interests, it’s important to reflect and describe those aspects beyond their superficial layer.

"It’s about looking back and getting to the meaningfulness of those experiences," says Mr. Stenger.

In everything they write, think:

  • What was gained?
  • How has it influenced me and others?
  • How has it changed me as a young person?

We understand this is a cumbersome process, but it’s important to encourage your children to try their best to show the ways they have enjoyed these experiences or how they have shaped them throughout their application.

7. Show Interest

Throughout all your children’s interactions with their school of choice, encourage them to demonstrate their interest.

How to demonstrate interest?

According to CollegeData, a member of the National Association for College Admission Counseling and an organization that helps students research and apply to colleges, there are four ways to demonstrate interest in the college application process.

  1. Build a track record of consistent contact. For example, when college advisors visit the school, encourage your children to speak to them, get their contact information, and send a thank-you note afterward.
  2. It’s important to show they’ve researched the school. For example, in their essays, bring up something they read on the school website or during one of its visits.
  3. Use their supplemental materials to their advantage. In many cases, essays on the college application will ask them something about why they want to attend this specific institution. Even if the application doesn't ask this, encourage your children to weave it into their answers.
  4. Apply early, well before the deadline, as this shows the college the applicant considers it one of their top choices.

Keep in mind: the school is tracking applicant interactions and therefore it’s important to be thoughtful with demonstrated interest.

What looks good on a college application - bonus tip!

Having access to a comprehensive college counseling program

You can encourage your children to paint the picture of their life outside of high school, write an articulate, vivid college essay, use their extensive vocabulary, have an impressive GPA, have recommendations from influential people in their life and make sure to showcase their sincerity throughout everything, but is that enough?

What can advance their college application even further is having access to a comprehensive college counseling program.

"Of course, the admissions process, no matter where it is in the world, is not an easy process for students or parents to navigate. Having someone who is committed to writing that process down and allowing the time necessary to make those decisions and put forth quality applications is always a win-win," says Mr. Stenger, speaking on the benefits of having a dedicated college counseling program.

At ISB, college counseling begins in Grade 9 and carries on throughout High School, intensifying as students near graduation.

The service includes:

  • A roadmap for both parents outlining major events and landmarks during their childrens’ High School years.
  • College seminars talking about admissions systems around the world. This is also a time where students and parents can have any questions answered.
  • University Kick-offs to work through personal reflections, college research and selecting universities and courses that are the right fit for students.
  • Research workshops.
  • College essay writing workshops.
  • Senior Retreat, where students get to meet with ISB alumni who tell them all about college.
“I think sometimes students themselves may not realize their potential. The counselors really help point those things out for them. When they have that person doing that for them, they feel more confident, more comfortable, they know that they’re going to have that support throughout the college process.”

--- Hiro W., a senior at ISB

Key takeaway

With all this in mind, it’s important to encourage your children to take their time when selecting which college or university to attend.

When selecting a post-secondary school, it’s highly recommended you, as a family, consider much more than the prestige of an institution, and focus on the importance of the school being a personal fit. Discover how to help your children choose a college that is right for them.